Scones & Suspicion: Crafting Whodunits with Flavor in Cozy Mystery Novels
- Kirsten Weiss
- Aug 2
- 4 min read
Hi, I’m Kirsten Weiss, and I write funny cozy mystery books with heart, clever puzzles, and a touch of the extraordinary.
Whether it’s a metaphysical detective or an amateur sleuth who owns a pie shop, food plays a starring role in my stories.
Today, I’m sharing the secret to writing cozy food porn — that delicious, immersive way of writing about food that makes readers’ mouths water and their hearts beat a little faster.
If you’re a fan of funny cozy mystery books, you’ve probably noticed how often food pops up — from scrumptious scones to warm and delicious pie.
But why is food so important, and how can you write it well?
Why Food Matters in Cozy Mystery Novels
Food is cozy.
We call some dishes comfort foods for a reason — they wrap us in warmth and nostalgia.
Food is life-sustaining, yes, but it’s also deeply emotional.
In cozy mystery novels, food often serves as more than just a backdrop; it’s a character in its own right.
Recipes tucked into the backs of cozy mysteries aren’t just a fun bonus — they’re a way to invite readers even deeper into the story’s world.
When you write about food well, readers may physically respond — their mouths water, cravings spark, and the book becomes more memorable and satisfying.
How to Write Food Well in Mystery Novels
First, don’t limit yourself to taste alone.
Think about all the senses that food engages.
- Smell:
The intoxicating aroma of fresh-baked scones or a rich cup of tea.
- Look:
The golden crust of a pie, the vibrant colors of a salad.
- Sound:
The satisfying crunch when a fork pierces a crispy crust or the gentle snap of a perfectly baked cookie.
- Texture:
The creaminess of a custard or the flaky layers of a croissant.
Layering these sensory details makes the food come alive on the page.
Next, write about the characters’ physical reactions to the food.
Is their mouth watering? Do their eyes light up? Is there a moment of bliss as they savor the first bite?
Food and Emotion: The Heart of Cozy Mystery Food Writing
Here’s where it gets really fun.
Food is tightly linked to memory and emotion.
This connection offers a beautiful opportunity to weave in backstory without it feeling like a heavy info-dump.
For example, I can’t look at a box of Red Vines without being transported back to childhood summers at the local pool.
I smell chlorine, hear the splash of water and the happy shrieks of children, and suddenly a simple candy becomes a portal to nostalgia.
Food can unlock emotions and memories for your characters, making their experiences richer and more relatable.
Food as a Cultural and Historical Touchstone
Food also offers a window into culture and history, which can be a delightful way to add depth to your mystery novel.
In my paranormal museum mystery, The Cannoli Caper, the crew visits Sicily, the birthplace of cannoli.
I write about the different variations Maddie encounters, the history of cannoli, and even some of the legends surrounding this iconic treat.
(And yes, there are recipes in the back of the book.)
In just a few sentences, you can take your readers on a mini food tour, enriching the setting and immersing them in the culture.
Setting the Mood and Tone with Food
Food can also set the mood or tone of a scene.
Think about how the temperature or spice level of food can symbolically reflect the emotions your characters are experiencing.
Imagine describing deviled eggs in a horror story versus a cozy mystery.
In horror, the yellow yolks might look jaundiced, the whites slick or chalky bone white — unsettling and eerie.
In a cozy mystery, those same deviled eggs are sunshine yellow, tangy, and delicious — inviting and comforting.
Layer that with the hero’s emotional reaction or memory, and you’ve got some seriously hot food writing.
The Sweet Science of Food and the Brain
Here’s a little neuroscience nugget that might blow your mind.
Sweet tastes activate the brain’s reward system and release dopamine.
This makes sweet flavors more memorable and tends to hook readers on a deeper level.
Now, I didn’t write my Pie Town or Tea and Tarot series with the intention of manipulating readers through sweet treats.
I just love pie and scones. 🤣
But this sweet connection is a powerful tool in cozy mystery writing.
Tying Food to Your Detective’s Heart
The real secret to food porn in cozy mysteries is tying food to your detective’s heart or past.
Food can become a part of the character’s identity, motivations, and emotional landscape.
This makes readers want to devour every page — and maybe even bake a batch of scones themselves.
What Food Evokes Strong Emotions for You?
Food is personal, and everyone has dishes that carry deep emotional weight.
Maybe it’s your grandmother’s chocolate chip cookies, a spicy curry that reminds you of home, or a simple bowl of soup that comforts you on a cold day.
In The Quiche and the Dead, Val's Abigail’s passion for pie is a funny foundation for her amateur crime-solving adventures with quirky pie-crust specialist, Charlene McCree.
Think about what food evokes powerful feelings for your characters and use that to enrich your mystery novel.
Bringing It All Together: Writing Cozy Mystery Novels with Food
When you write cozy mysteries, food is more than just fuel for your characters.
It’s a way to build atmosphere, deepen character, and connect readers emotionally to the story.
By engaging all the senses, tapping into memory and culture, and setting the mood through food, you can create a rich, satisfying reading experience.
And don’t forget the power of sweet tastes to activate readers’ brains and keep them hooked.
If you want to see these ideas in action, check out The Quiche and the Dead, book one in my Pie Town series of funny cozy mysteries.
It’s packed with tasty mysteries and, of course, pie recipes in the back.
Happy writing — and happy eating!
Comments